News, Vision & Voice for the Advisory Community
Alex Murguia is assembling a minor Dream Team of RIA execs including Zohar Swaine, but the revenue model is causing some consternation
January 7, 2013 — 4:20 AM UTC by Lisa Shidler
Brooke’s Note: InStream has one of those semi-grotesque tech-bubble-era amalgamated names that means little to most people. An understanding of what the company’s technology does requires a Ph.D. in deciphering technology marketers. But inStream also has some believers who know far more about technology than I do, and its founder is an RIA with a track record of big growth. The software is also appealing in that it goes to the nub of the issue for financial advisors — financial planning. See: How RIAs like Aspiriant and United Capital are working to put financial planning back at the center of financial planning firms. It was enough to convince us that we should put aside our petty biases and take a good look at just how much the smoke indicates fire at this Beltway firm.
Every once in a while a whiff of the next big thing for an industry comes along. From the financial planning software arena, there are signs that inStream Solutions LLC is making a viable bid for that spot.
The problem with financial plans is that they are a static solution to a dynamic problem. They are as dumb as that traffic signal that stops you with a red light when there are no other cars coming for five miles in any direction. A person’s life and the markets change by the minute and the pages of financial plans often turn yellow before they get an update. InStream is taking a major stab at creating a smart plan by linking up the plans to real-time data.
Better yet, the software sends information back to the cloud where its becomes grist for the grander mill of users hooked in around the country.
RIAs will also get alerts about important changes that affect a person’s financial plan, such as mortgage interest rates going down. See: How RIAs are becoming as complacent as wirehouses — and what it’ll take to snap out of it.
In just a year, McLean, Va.-based technology firm has 1,300 advisors using the software and has received enthusiastic accolades from industry analysts, among them Bill Winterberg principal of Atlanta-based FPPad.com. , which just bestowed on InStream innovation of the Year award which appeared on Morningstar’s website. The technology is part of the arsenals of TD Ameritrade, Schwab Advisor Services and Orion Advisor Services LLC.
Dream tech team
InStream was dreamed up by Alex Murguia, 40, who created the tool while serving as an advisor at McLean (Va.) Asset Management Corp., a firm that has seen its assets soar from $25 million to more than $600 million in a decade. Murguia is creating his own technology dream-team, recently recruiting Zohar Swaine, former managing director of TD Ameritrade’s Institutional Strategy and product organizations, as president, and John Wotowicz as executive chairman. Wotowicz is a former board member for Dimensional Fund Advisors LP.
Murguia also recruited as a board member Peter Corsell, whom MIT lauded as one of the top innovators under the age of 35. See: How McLean Asset Management is adding practices without making acquisitions.
“They are changing the paradigm of planning software,” says Spenser Segal, chief executive of ActiFi Inc.. They’ve got the sharpest people in the entire industry working on this project. I’ve known Zohar and Alex for years. If things don’t go according to plan, these folks won’t stick their heads in the sand; they’ll continue to evolve the company.”
On top of all those things — this is a product that costs RIAs absolutely nothing — a minor trend is evolving. See: Advisor Tested: Market76 is trying to be a better, cheaper platform for advisors — free, in fact.
But sometimes when something seems too good to be true, it is. While the product is free to advisors, one major aspect of the firm’s revenue model is that it will offer products through its software and get a commission when RIAs choose them. The firm has created aspects of its marketplace model but intends to fully launch this section of the platform this year.
There is a potential conflict of interest anytime a firm is being compensated for financial advice, says David Loeper, chairman and CEO of Wealth Care Capital Management Inc. His firm recently settled with UBS Financial Services Inc. over the patent infringement lawsuit against UBS pertaining to his firm’s financial planning patent. See: MoneyGuidePro back on a roll after the.
“When it comes to being an advocate for clients, I think a real independent fiduciary doesn’t earn bribes from anyone and that’s what commission is. I could see it as a potential conflict of interest. Anytime you accept commission from an outside entity and you’re trying to enable distribution to financial advisors, I can’t help but see there are conflicts that arise and I think it’s how they manage them.”
Loeper says he feels that this program reminds him of “pay-to-play” programs back in the 1980s where brokerage firms offered up managed-account and mutual fund “select” lists. “If you think about many advisor tools today, that’s what a lot of them do — create a sales presentation, often under a guise of analysis. Numbers may be crunched, but where is objective client-centered wisdom?”
In response, Swaine says the firm doesn’t seek to limit the advisor’s choices on behalf of clients but instead wants to offer a wide range of companies that represent hundreds of products.
“We’re striking deals with brokers who have an array of products, and that helps the advisor to bridge the fiduciary responsibilities. inStream does not intend to limit an advisor’s choice of which financial provider to use — this key point may have been misreported or not understood by others. In fact, any information provided through inStream may help an advisor meet their fiduciary responsibility,” Swaine says. “Providing transparency is the hallmark of fiduciary responsibility. What inStream provides is the platform to manage the marketplace selection process.”
inStream will not sell data it receives from RIAs, Swaine says.
Murguia feels that the marketplace solution is better than the options available to RIAs now because the technology will get them a wide range of solutions for products such as insurance and mortgages. “What are advisors faced with right now — well, right now many of them are calling their cousin who is a broker or someone down the road who happens to be convenient. This will give them an opportunity to see a unified marketplace and allow them to flex their fiduciary muscles as opposed to handcuff them,” he says.
No fiduciary concerns
But advisor Greg Brown, who was a mutual fund analyst at Morningstar for four years and recently started his own RIA, Pathway Financial Planning LLC, in Novi, Mich., says he doesn’t feel the marketplace product poses a fiduciary problem at all.
He compares inStream to popular consumer company Mint.com. “I use Mint.com and I ignore the marketplace, but with inStream I’m not sure I’ll ignore it. The life insurance quotes are very straightforward and competitive. I think it would actually be pretty valuable.”
Brown has $4 million in assets and had been usingMoneyGuidePro, spending about $1,000 annually for the software, before switching just weeks ago to inStream.
Not exactly MoneyGuidePro yet
“I really like what they’ve done so far,” he says. 'I’m really excited about where they’re headed. They don’t have full functionality of a financial planning software like MoneyGuidePro. But I found that I didn’t use everything in MoneyGuidePro so I was OK with that. They have about 80% of what MoneyGuidePro offers, and that’s really what I needed.”
Other industry leaders say they feel the marketplace concept will give RIAs a perfect opportunity to shop around for the best products for their clients.
“By definition, no marketplace has every available option, but I certainly don’t think that’s a big issue. The RIAs can still shop outside of the marketplace,” Segal says. “I would view this marketplace as an addition to the processes that advisors use to find the right solutions for clients.
One of the key differentiators between this software and others in the industry is the fact that the planning software is updated daily, says Winterberg.
Winterberg points out that that traditional planning software has been stagnant for years. Typically, advisors include data for each client’s household and when they change or update that plan, they look at each plan individually and update all of the pertinent information. What’s different here is the technology provides alerts to RIAs about changes in a client’s circumstances.
“Today, advisors create financial plans largely in a vacuum, one-by-one, often by manually updating interest, mortgage and insurance rates,” says Winterberg. “inStream will soon use plan data aggregated across thousands of plans and hundreds of advisors to identify trends and general practices based on a variety of demographics and client characteristics.”
inStream tracks the changes in the marketplace and compares that information with the existing data in an RIA’s financial plans. If interest rates change to become a benefit to clients, then an RIA would get an alert detecting that the client could save money by refinancing at a lower rate. RIAs can set ceilings and floors for specific plan outcomes to control how often they receive alerts.
Social media component
The rapid updates the software provides should be a strong attraction for RIAs, Eric Clarke of Orion Advisor Services, LLC, says advisors like the alerts.
“Advisors love the proactive nature of the alert,” Clarke says. “Instead of [an advisor’s] looking at a client’s mortgage right before [a meeting], inStream will scan mortgage rates and notify advisors if there are lower rates available. This is technology built for advisors by advisors. What they offer we integrate with inStream and it works very well with them. It’s a compatible offering.”
Clarke says that another unique aspect of inStream’s offering is how it enables — social-media style — RIAs to compare their recommendations to those of other RIAs. “inStream has some pretty neat social-media aspects about their platform that others don’t have,” Clarke says.
Murguia credits his firm’s top talent for creating the software.
He points to Swaine — who was formerly managing director of TD Ameritrade’s institutional strategy and product organizations. At TD Amertrade, Swaine’s group was credited with winning Winterberg’s 2011 Best Back-Office Technology Award as a result of the Veo Open Access program. Swaine is president of inStream. See: TD Ameritrade’s promise of creating an RIA version of Apple’s app store may have found its prototype signing.
Wotowicz was a managing director at Morgan Stanley, where he founded Europe’s leveraged finance industry and was ultimately responsible for oversight of the firm’s European investment banking business as a member of the European Investment Banking Operating Committee.
In addition, Bryan Lee, who was a managing director at McLean Asset Management, is now inStream’s COO. Bob French, its director of advisor services, was most recently with DFA’s financial advisor services group.
“It’s impressive building out this whole team that we’ve been able to bring on board,” Murguia says. “This is a world-class team being put together on many fronts. Not many times have we had an opportunity to redefine the industry as it moves from investment- orientated advice to one of wealth management. So far, the software hasn’t caught up with it.”
Wooing the talent
While executives at inStream declined to delve into how they’re attracting this talent, it appears that it involves a combination of top salaries and equity stakes in the firm.
“The primary factor in recruiting top talent in these environments is a passion for the product and a strong belief in the underlying value proposition. I fall squarely into this camp, as do all of my colleagues,” Swaine says.
Mentioned in this article:
Financial Planning Software
Top Executive: Alex Murguia
Portfolio Management System, Trading/Rebalancing
Top Executive: Dave Miller
Share your thoughts and opinions with the author or other readers.